Top 5 of the best eye pencils

Eye pencils are an essential must-have for bold makeup, especially to enhance the eyes. Whatever type of pencil you choose or how you apply it, you can reshape the eyes or intensify their color by playing with contrasts. Whether you are a beginner or skilled in eye makeup, having the best eye pencil will always be an asset for achieving a flawless result.

If you don’t choose the right product, you may encounter issues such as: the tip breaking in the sharpener, smudging on the eyelids, ingredients that may cause irritation or conjunctivitis, or color that doesn’t last all day… Our makeup experts have selected the 5 best eye pencils to help you create the boldest looks.

• Eye pencils come in several types: kohl, kajal, retractable, waterproof, or cream, to choose according to the desired effect and your needs.
• To avoid the “panda eyes” effect, opt for a long-lasting or waterproof pencil, especially if you have oily skin or watery eyes.
• A dry formula is suitable for oily skin, while a slightly creamy texture is ideal for dry skin to keep eyelids hydrated.
• Always apply the pencil from the outer corner of the eye toward the inner corner, on clean and lightly powdered eyelids, without layering too much.
• For sensitive eyes, choose a high-tolerance, ophthalmologically tested pencil, such as those from La Roche-Posay, Eye Care Cosmetics, or Clinique.
• A well-sharpened pencil with a fine tip ensures precise application and a clean result, whether for a subtle line or a smokey effect.

What is the difference between a kohl pencil, kajal, retractable pencil, eye pen, multi-use pencil, or one designed specifically for the eye contour? Generally, four main criteria influence your choice: color, texture, staying power, and ease of use.

When it comes to eye pencils, black is the most popular shade. However, many brands struggle to deliver an ultra-intense pigmentation that doesn’t fade into a greyish tone once applied. For a deep ebony finish, it is best to choose kajal pencils or highly pigmented leads that enhance the eyes in just one stroke.

If you have oily or acne-prone skin, your eyelids may cause makeup to smudge more easily. Using an oily texture can increase the risk of smudging throughout the day, leading to the dreaded “panda eyes” effect. In this case, opt for a pencil with a drier formula and consider using an eyelid primer to prevent smudging. Conversely, if you have dry skin, a slightly creamy pencil will help hydrate your eyelids and ensure longer wear.

An easy-to-apply pencil should not cause discomfort on the waterline or lower lash line. It is important not to block the tear ducts, as product particles entering the eye can cause irritation and watering, which may lead to makeup running. Make sure to use a pencil that you tolerate well.

One of the most common issues is poor staying power around the eye contour. Nothing is more frustrating than pigment gathering in the inner corner or a pencil that smudges and creates dark circles around the eyes. To avoid “panda eyes,” it is highly recommended to use long-lasting or waterproof pencils, especially if your eyes tend to water.

Matte pencil:

If applying a liquid eyeliner feels too difficult, matte eye contour pencils are a great alternative to enhance the eyes. Thanks to their long-lasting formula and smooth glide along the upper lash line, they allow you to create precise, clean lines without smudging. After a few seconds, the finish becomes matte and the product stays in place. Just make sure to sharpen them regularly to keep the tip fine and precise.

Waterproof pencil:

When wearing makeup daily, there are many reasons why eyeliner may run: rain, tears, or sweating due to heat. To ensure long-lasting eye makeup, opt for the best waterproof eye pencils available. They are designed to resist water, humidity, and heat. Available in various shades and sometimes with glitter finishes, they can be semi-permanent. Kohl pencils can also be used to create precise eyeliner looks, delivering an intense line in a single stroke. For a smokey effect, some pencils even come with built-in smudgers for a more dramatic look. Make sure to use a good micellar water or cleansing milk to remove your eye makeup.

Kohl or kajal, what’s the difference?

Historically, kohl was a black powder and is now a key ingredient in most eye pencils. Kajal has a different composition and is usually made from a soft, creamy cone containing plant butters and camphor. Kohl originates from ancient Egypt, while kajal comes from regions of India. Both have been traditionally used for their beneficial properties for the eyes.

The eyelids are the thinnest and most delicate part of the skin, which makes them particularly sensitive. In addition, the presence of eyelashes and tear ducts can increase the risk of eye issues such as conjunctivitis or keratitis. This is why it is important to pay close attention to the quality of the eye pencils you choose, their ingredients, and how you apply them.

To achieve a natural and flattering result, apply the pencil from the outer corner of the eye toward the inner corner, without applying too much pressure on the waterline. Avoid layering too many strokes to prevent clumping.

If you wear glasses that magnify your eyes, it is recommended to apply the pencil on the inside of the lower eyelid to reduce the magnifying effect. On the other hand, if you want to make your eyes look bigger, apply it along the outer lash line. You can also use a nude or white pencil on the inner eye to enhance this effect.

For a cat-eye look, use your pencil to draw a line on the upper eyelid. You can blend it with a brush or a smudging tip to create a smokey or dramatic effect—the possibilities are endless!

1. Avril – Charcoal Black Eye Pencil

Minimalist, effective, and certified organic, the Avril charcoal black eye pencil is ideal for those looking for natural makeup without compromising on intensity.

Its natural-origin formula delivers deep black pigmentation while respecting the delicate eye contour area. Its soft tip glides smoothly without irritation and allows for a clean, buildable line depending on the desired intensity.

Why we love it:

• Certified organic and vegan formula
• Intense black without grey undertones
• Suitable for sensitive eyes
• Excellent value for money

2. Clinique – Cream Shaper for Eyes 1.2 g

A true reference in high-tolerance makeup, Clinique’s Cream Shaper is an ultra-comfortable cream pencil that combines smooth glide, precision, and long-lasting wear.

Its creamy texture allows easy application, even on the waterline, without smudging throughout the day. It is especially appreciated by sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Key benefits:

• Ultra-soft creamy texture
• Excellent smudge-proof wear
• Ophthalmologist-tested
• Perfect for an intense yet comfortable look

3. La Roche-Posay – Toleriane Eye Pencil

Specially formulated for ultra-sensitive eyes, the Toleriane eye pencil by La Roche-Posay is a must-have in dermo-cosmetics.

Its high-tolerance, fragrance-free, and ophthalmologist-tested formula allows you to define the eyes safely. Its soft tip minimizes friction and respects the eye’s delicate mucous membrane.

Ideal if you have:

• Sensitive or allergy-prone eyes
• Contact lenses
• Reactive skin
• A need for safe everyday makeup

4. Eye Care Cosmetics – High-Tolerance Eye Contour Pencil

Developed in collaboration with ophthalmologists, this Eye Care Cosmetics pencil is designed for very sensitive, allergic, or fragile eyes.

Its high-tolerance formula ensures precise application, good staying power, and excellent compatibility with the eye contour area. It is perfectly suited for daily use, even in cases of eye dryness.

Key strengths:

• Ophthalmological formula
• Suitable for allergy-prone eyes
• Good wear without smudging
• Safe and comfortable makeup

5. IT Cosmetics – Superhero Eye Set (Full-Size Mascara + Eyeshadow Stick)

More than just an eye pencil, this IT Cosmetics set is a complete solution to enhance your eyes. The eyeshadow stick helps define and intensify the eye contour, while the Superhero mascara delivers extreme volume and definition.

Formulated with skincare ingredients, this makeup-care duo respects the delicate eye area while delivering professional-looking results.

Why this set stands out:

• Makeup + skincare in one step
• Easy-to-blend texture
• Enhanced eyes without heaviness
• Suitable for sensitive eyes